Second Sunday of Easter (Year A)
April 16, 2023
First Lutheran Church of the Reformation, New Britain, CT
19When it was evening on that day, the first day of the week, and the doors of the house where the disciples had met were locked for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood among them and said, “Peace be with you.” 20After he said this, he showed them his hands and his side. Then the disciples rejoiced when they saw the Lord. 21Jesus said to them again, “Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, so I send you.” 22When he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. 23If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.”
24But Thomas (who was called the Twin), one of the twelve, was not with them when Jesus came. 25So the other disciples told him, “We have seen the Lord.” But he said to them, “Unless I see the mark of the nails in his hands, and put my finger in the mark of the nails and my hand in his side, I will not believe.”
26A week later his disciples were again in the house, and Thomas was with them. Although the doors were shut, Jesus came and stood among them and said, “Peace be with you.” 27Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger here and see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it in my side. Do not doubt but believe.” 28Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” 29Jesus said to him, “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe.”
30Now Jesus did many other signs in the presence of his disciples, which are not written in this book. 31But these are written so that you may come to believe that Jesus is the Messiah, the Son of God, and that through believing you may have life in his name. – John 20:19-29
The disciples are grieving. At the beginning of this story, they are still uncertain about the news of the resurrection – they know Jesus’s body is missing. The women have made reports to them. But they have not yet seen. They no doubt want to believe but can’t quite yet.
If you’ve ever grieved the loss of someone you love, you can imagine the longing the disciples have been feeling since that fateful Friday afternoon. Longing for one more chance to speak with the one you love, one last chance for an embrace, one more moment together. What the disciples wouldn’t give this Sunday evening for a hug from Jesus. Hold that in your mind for a moment – longing for an embrace by Jesus, longing to be held, reassured, comforted.
I want to pause there and think for a moment about just what a hug is. Theologian Miroslav Volf describes an embrace in 4 parts:
First, you open your arms like a door left open to welcome a dear friend.
Second, you wait. If you do not wait, the embrace is coercive, forced. Waiting for the other is key.
Third, when the person comes you close your arms. There is connection. The two do not become the same, become one, but they are changed by their relation to the other – each giving and receiving something from the other.
And finally, fourth, this is key, you open your arms again. The two separate. They are changed but once again apart, now available, open, ready for another embrace.
Now, this may sound a little strange to dissect such a natural and intimate gesture into component parts. But bear with me.
The disciples are longing for Jesus’ embrace. But they are also deeply afraid. No one can blame them. They are at risk of suffering the same violent death as their friend and teacher. They are uncertain whether the empty tomb and stories of Jesus appearing have any merit or if that is one more thing they must fear. And so, despite longing for Jesus’ embrace, they gather in a room, closed the door, and lock it tight. It brings a momentary sense of security, but it is also the exact opposite of what they long for. They long for an embrace from Jesus, but they have closed their arms by locking the door. Without arms open, how will they welcome an embrace.
But this is what fear does to us. We are afraid of our security so we turn to violence whether with guns in our communities or armies to fight wars on our behalf. And what we often get is not security but more violence.
We are afraid of losing what we have so we clutch more tightly to what we have so much so that we sometimes squeeze the life out of it. We do that with money – crossing the line from healthy financial planning for the future to tight-fisted management of money forgoing the things that might give us joy and failing to share it with those whose lives could depend on our generosity.
We are afraid of dying and so we shut out any talk of death. We try to hide signs of aging, we glorify unrealistic youthful bodies, and we come up with all manner of euphemisms to avoid ever saying that someone has died.
And friends, I fear that we are a fearful church. Not just you here at First, but our churches as a whole. I worry that too often the disciples locked away out of fear is an ideal metaphor for the moment we find ourselves in.
We fear losing the traditions that have been meaningful to us, and fail to welcome new ones that might bring the Spirit’s breath into our midst. We fear losing beloved buildings and congregations, and in that fear cling so tightly to it that we bring about our worst fears. We fear changes, we fear risks, we fear the things Jesus might call us to step out of our comfort zone to do.
We long for God’s embrace, and new people, and new energy, and a vibrant future. But instead of opening our arms, we too often lock our doors instead. Maybe – hopefully! – not literally locking our doors to keep out others. But sometimes we get so caught up in God’s embracing us that we forget to open our arms back up to welcome the next person in need of embrace. Or our embrace is unintentionally coercive or fails to allow ourselves to be changed by the presence of the newcomer. Or sometimes we’re too afraid to even experience God’s life-changing embrace in the first place.
It feels safe to stay locked in the room. There is anxiety, but it is familiar and protected. The locked room is its own kind of embrace, one that doesn’t quite follow the full pattern.
But this is where Jesus enters. Ignoring the closed and locked door, Jesus, fully embodied, fully resurrected stands before them in the room. The lock may or may not have kept out someone wanting to cause them harm, but it has no power to keep out the life-changing presence of God.
Jesus stands with them, his very presence the embrace they have been longing for. His breath upon them easing their fear. His word of peace reminding them of what God can do even in the midst of death and violence.
They may have closed and locked their door, they may have been overcome by fear. But the resurrected Christ breaks in to set them free. In doing so he reminds them of their deep call to go out from their locked room and offer embrace to the world, to offer the same peace they have felt just now to others.
This is the good news. Even when we as people and as institutions act out of fear, God sets us free over and over again to be God’s people in the world.
Perhaps we might place ourselves in Thomas’s shoes for a moment – the one who is left of out of Jesus first appearance among them. He wants to believe, wants more than anything to see and touch. But he cannot yet ready himself for what comes next until he gets that chance. Once he does he is flooded with relief, with peace, with energy, with faith. And then he, too, is ready.
As we make decisions for ourselves, for our church, for our community, maybe we can pause and ask ourselves whether this is a decision out of fear or faith. Are we locking the door so that we can feel secure, or are we reaching out, opening our arms, and taking a risk so that we might share God’s embrace with the world?
When we realize we are making decisions out of fear, what are our touchpoints, the places where we can be reassured of Christ’s resurrected presence among us, to remind us again of the power of God to support us and resurrect us? Perhaps it is this Sunday morning worship where we encounter Christ in bread and wine, in water and word, in song and fellowship. Maybe it is in serving our neighbor where we meet Christ in the oppressed and hungry, the imprisoned and sick – encountering the presence of the resurrected Christ in our fellow human beings and in the imperiled natural world. Maybe it is in personal devotions, sabbath rest, or in the intricacies of science or art or dance. Where is it that you have touched the risen Christ?
When we connect with those moments of Christ’s touch in our lives overpowering our fear, experiencing the risen one, what is that feeling? Does it feel like the locked up room, or does it feel like a brave and exhilarating energy that drives you to do the things that seemed impossible before?
What adventures is the resurrected Christ calling you to here at First? Is it in the call of your next pastor to lead you into something new? Is it in the releasing of resources to serve the needs of the community and the church at large? Is it in expanding the connection to your neighbors and serving more people?
Beloved ones, God has embraced you in a gesture of grace and peace. God has broken down your walls to be present among you. Now you are being called to open your arms from that embrace, forever changed, forever free to embrace others. Go forth, then, arms open wide and hearts ready to welcome. Because God is doing something new and inviting you to be a part.
-Pastor Steven Wilco