11th Sunday after Pentecost
August 9, 2026
Trinity Episcopal Church, Shrewsbury with Good Shepherd, Clinton
A full recording of worship including this sermon is available on Trinity’s Facebook page:
22 [Jesus] made the disciples get into a boat and go on ahead to the other side [of the Sea of Galilee,] while he dismissed the crowds.23 And after he had dismissed the crowds, he went up the mountain by himself to pray. When evening came, he was there alone, 24 but by this time the boat, battered by the waves, was far from the land, for the wind was against them. 25 And early in the morning he came walking toward them on the sea. 26 But when the disciples saw him walking on the sea, they were terrified, saying, “It is a ghost!” And they cried out in fear. 27 But immediately Jesus spoke to them and said, “Take heart, it is I; do not be afraid.”
28 Peter answered him, “Lord, if it is you, command me to come to you on the water.” 29 He said, “Come.” So Peter got out of the boat, started walking on the water, and came toward Jesus. 30 But when he noticed the strong wind, he became frightened, and, beginning to sink, he cried out, “Lord, save me!” 31 Jesus immediately reached out his hand and caught him, saying to him, “You of little faith, why did you doubt?” 32 When they got into the boat, the wind ceased. 33 And those in the boat worshiped him, saying, “Truly you are the Son of God.” – Matthew 14:22-33
“Fear not!” cries many a biblical messenger. Go for it! Try something new! God is calling! Take on the mantle of a prophet, leave your homeland and become the ancestors of nations, bear the son of God within your womb, get out of the boat and walk on water.
Experimenting and bold risk-taking have their appeal. Who among us hasn’t read some of the Biblical stories with awe and wonder questioning whether we could ever have the courage to do what the Biblical heroes do? We’d like to think we’d take a step out of the boat and walk on water at Jesus’ invitation, but perhaps we also fear we might not actually have it in us.
But the interesting thing is that in pretty much every biblical story arc, the biblical hero experiences failure. Things don’t work as planned. Something falls apart. Abraham and Sarah lie and get themselves in a terrible pickle. David commits murder and adultery. Prophet after prophet speaks truth to ears that will not hear. Peter falls into the water. And Jesus…well…Jesus dies a horrible death as a criminal. We remember these stories because it is God’s work leading fallible human beings through to something new.
And yet, we still think of failure as something bad. In a column several years ago by medical researcher Eileen Parkes, she says this about her work and the work of scientists in general: “Failure is something that all scientists experience – but it is hard to tell looking at our shiny conferences, polished presentations, and glossy journals. Comfortable science is an oxymoron. If we want to make new discoveries, that means taking a leap in the dark – a leap we might not take if we are afraid to fail.”
I think the same could be said of theology, specifically the lived theology of being church in the world – failure is something all people of faith experience; comfortable church is an oxymoron; if we want to make new discoveries about God, about ourselves we can’t be afraid of failure.
Take the disciples in the boat in today’s gospel reading. Jesus sent them out across the Sea of Galilee. It’s a familiar place for the disciples. Even the non-fishermen know the area intimately. And the fishermen among them have been out in all manner of calm and storm in this small but sometimes volatile lake. When the storm arises, they go into action. They are busy steering and stabilizing, trying to keep the bow pointed into the waves and get to the shore they are trying to reach. None of them want to be in the storm.
Can you relate? Do you ever feel like you are in the midst of storm you didn’t create, a storm you didn’t want, a storm you didn’t ask to be out in. We didn’t ask for economic struggle, generational changes. We didn’t ask for entrenched inequality, hunger, and homelessness or a way of life that has created drastic climate change. We didn’t ask for illness and death that visits our families all too often. We didn’t ask for political strife and scandal at every level and across both major parties. We didn’t ask for cultural shifts that make it harder to carry on as churches in the way we have in decades past.
Yet, here we are, trying to keep our boat afloat in the midst of it all. Jesus sometimes feels absent. And when he does show up, his words are, what? “Don’t be afraid?” I don’t know about you, but sometimes those words feel as if Jesus is a little out of touch with what’s going on. The disciples are in a storm! And now what they think is a ghost has come to them in the midst of it! Don’t be afraid? Why the heck not?
Blessed Peter, rather than shirking back, doubling down on his grip on the rail of the boat, tests to see if it really is Jesus. Even for an experienced fisherman, this seems risky. The whole scene would be much more comfortable if Jesus calmed the storm first, clearly identified himself, and then joined them in the boat. Or at least let them all hang on til he got in. But in the midst of crashing waves and howling wind, Peter steps out.
From there we all know the feeling – suddenly realizing just how dangerous our particular plan is. The feeling when one is strapped into a roller coaster and the chain starts clicking the car up the hill – the fear is now palpable but there is nothing Peter can do about it on his own. Into the crashing waves he begins to sink. The rush of cold water, the feeling of gasping for air, flailing arms reaching – seeking anything that feels firm in the midst of the storm.
It’s easy to feel like we’re drowning. The pace of life alone and all the storms of life that crash around us on a daily basis. Reaching for a solid place to stand and finding none.
Into this Jesus grabs onto Peter. Grabs a hold of us. The storm continues to rage. The water is still cold. We are not yet on solid ground. But God has a hold of us.
A life of faith is not lived on solid ground or in a place of safety and comfort. A life of faith is lived in the midst of the storm, having taken risks that leave us open to even more challenges. But always with God’s grasp on us, holding on to us and refusing to let us go.
The storms of life make it sometimes hard to take one more risk. We want church and faith to be a safe haven, a solid ark in the storm. In some ways, of course, it is. It’s a place we come to hear familiar promises, to share the familiar meal, to sing the familiar songs. It’s a place we tune in to God’s firm and loving and life-saving grip on us.
But it’s also the place that God calls us to take those risky steps out of the boat, a place that God calls us deeper into the storm for the sake of even deeper recognition of God’s love and grace.
That’s work you’ve already done. Good Shepherd folks who are present today – you took a big bold step out of the boat in selling your building and figuring out what it means to do ministry more nimbly from the same location in a different way. Trinity folks, you saw the deep need in your community and began a diaper ministry. It grew way bigger than you anticipated and now you are doing an amazing thing but looking for that solid foundation to keep meeting the growing need.
I wish I could stand here and say to you, “Well done! You’ve taken a bold risk in ministry, and now you get to cruise comfortably on calm waters.” But you know as well as I do that’s not the case. This is not a one-time event, but an over and over again calling from God to step out into the storm.
One of the things church does for me, perhaps especially the celebration of the Eucharist together, is remind me that in reaching out to hold onto us, God invites us then to also be the hands that reach out and hold others in the storm. Others who may or may not recognize that it is God’s firm foundation that makes it possible. Others who experience the storms in similar and different ways. How is God calling you as faith communities, us as a diocese, and all of us as individuals into the next bold risk in the midst of it?
We may fear that taking that step will look to the world and even to ourselves like failure. It may very well look like falling head first into the crashing waters. And yet, with God’s presence with us in the storm, that failure is simply part of the incredible journey of faith we live held firmly in God’s loving grasp.
-Pastor Steven Wilco
